Thursday, January 13, 2011

Inferno

Discuss the meaning of the sign over the Gate of Hell in Canto II, especially the significance of lines 4-6.

17 comments:

  1. It makes sense how the architect of Hell, God, would use divine omnipotence and ultimate intellect to create Hell. The third thing however, primordial love, struck me when I was first reading Canto II. After thinking about it however, I think I understand why it was included. My reasoning was that God loves everyone- sinner or non-sinner, and no matter what anyone could possibly do, he has eternal love for them. God especially loves/puts love into everything he creates- people, creatures of all sorts, and even Hell.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Primordial is defined as something "pertaining to or existing at or from the very beginning." In this case it applies to the primordial love of God. Meaning that God's love has always been around, also, it is equating God with love. I took this to be a kind of reminder for those going into hell that they were always given the chance while on earth to live out God's love. However, this would not explain why divine omnipotence and ultimate intellect are included in the description of God. Which they all serve as -- simply a description of God. God is power, God is knowledge, and God is love.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Upon first reading Canto II I was a little confused with why primordial was describing love. The other two phrases on the architect of Hell made more sense: Omnipotence refers to having unlimited power. Divine goes well with this word because God has unlimited power and he is the Divine Creator. Intellect refers to knowledge. I understood unlimited intellect as the need to understand everything in order to not make mistakes. Looking back, I think that primordial love can refer to God's mercy. No matter what,there is a way out and the honor of God's grace.

    ReplyDelete
  4. When Mr. Seeberg mentioned to think about the idea of a prison when trying to rationalize Dante's use of "primordial love," I asked myself why people are put into prison, rather than trying to think directly about the abstract idea of hell. I realized that people are put into prison to protect the innocent citizens of the world from more harm. People that are in prison have broken the law. Perhaps it is possible, then, that those souls in hell are being kept away from the good souls in heaven, the souls that have stuck to the law. When thinking about it like that, God’s love becomes a protective love. God, then, made hell to help all of the good souls in heaven to stay pure. When he was making it, it is possible that he was not thinking about punishing the bad, but protecting and loving the good.

    ReplyDelete
  5. God, the architect of the Gate of Hell, used divine omnipotence, ultimate intellect, and primordial love to create Hell. God, the divine creator, used each of these things in his construction of hell, and ultimately the world. I agree with Kelly in the idea that God has eternal love for all people, thus using primordial love to create the Gate of Hell. God contains and uses his unlimited power, knowledge, and love for everyone. He is setting the scene for Hell, although sinners enter, this gate is a sign of God's love for all of creation.

    ReplyDelete
  6. God was the architect of the Gate to Hell and has three main points to present to the sinners who are entering hell. These three main points that compose hell are omnipotence, premordial love, and ultimate intellect. God is the only person who obtains unlimited knowledge and has love for all people. He uses his knowledge and love for all and reminds the sinners of what they are losing while they enter eternal hell.

    ReplyDelete
  7. God is the architect of the Gate of Hell which he designed through sacred justice's three parts: Divine omnipotence, primordial love, and ultimate intellect. It makes sense that God would create Hell with intellect and divine power, but primordial love is a bit more surprising. I thought that Martha made an interesting point in saying that maybe Hell is created out of love, in the sense that the love is protective of the good people in heaven. However, I think it more has to do with the fact that God loves all creation, sinners and non-sinners, even though the sinners have chosen to reject God's love.

    ReplyDelete
  8. The inscription above the gate to Hell has a lot of symbolism. The incsription says 3 things:divine omnipotence, primordial love, and ultimate intellct. Right away you notice that the number three is used and that is no accident. At first when I read this, I didn't think much about it. But after we talked in class, I thought about the symbolism of the number three and I remembered that the Holy Trinity has three parts and the inscription might be a reference to that. The Holy Trinity is made up of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. You can see the inscription on the gate as another representation of the Holy Trinity: God the Father has divine omnipotence (power), God the Son has ultimate intellect (wisdom), and God the Holy Spirit has primordial love (from the beginning, love for all).

    ReplyDelete
  9. Upon entering the gates of Hell, Dante encounters the inscription said in lines 1-9 of the third canto. Dante uses this declaration to show the reader that even Hell was created by the divine. By saying that “sacred justice moved my architect,” Dante suggests that God was the ultimate creator of Hell, and that he designed everything in it. He furthers this observation with the hidden symbols found within the “architecture of Hell.” This creation by God is shown in terms of the Holy Trinity. Divine omnipotence represents the Holy Father, ultimate intellect reflects the son, and finally primordial love symbolizes the Holy Spirit. Dante subtlety included this reference to the Catholic faith, while at the same time retaining his love for the number 3. All in all, Dante included these potent lines in order to illustrate the importance the divine had on the building of Hell.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I admit that when first reading this line, I thought of the number 3 and how Dante may have used it in the sense of the Trinity. The omnipotence refers to the Holy Spirit, the ultimate intellect refers to the Son, and the primordial love is left to God the Father. It is from the teachings of Jesus that we hear the God loves all people regardless of what they do, so ultimately this extends onto the afterlife whether they end up in hell, heaven, or purgatory. I also agree with Martha in the fact that although God loves all, it may be a protective love and how this is for the best to keep the people who did their best in life away from those who did not choose to do their best. In conclusion, this architect uses the primordial love to mean more than one thing.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Ultimate intellect and divine omnipotence are easy to understand about God, the architect of hell. Primordial love is a bit different however. Primordial means "pertaining to or existing at or from the very beginning". This then makes the line suggest that God's love is the only reason he does anything and that God himself is Love. For me, the love part fits because I believe hell was created to make people want to be in heaven. The love he put into creating a place for sinners was the love He used to let people join him in heaven. Also, since Hell was created by God who is Love, than it had to have been made with the eternal Love.

    ReplyDelete
  12. When Dante reads the inscription over the gate of hell, it immediatley tells him who built hell and why. Obviously the architect was God since it was built before time began and was built with sacred justice. The reason that God built Hell was to punish all of the sinners, but he did it out of love. i think that this means that even though these people did wrong, they are still thought of by God. I thiunk thast God punishes them with the same mentality of how we punish children. If a child misbehaves we punish them, and if a child severly misbehaves we punish them more. So these people have been sinning their entire lives so they deserve a large punishment. The reason God punishes them is because he wants for them to learn from their mistakes and ultimatly become better people.

    ReplyDelete
  13. The inscription on the sign above hell struck me like everybody us did because it talks about primordial love. Intellect and omnipotence make sense but the part about love can be confusing. A lot of people have been saying that hell is primordial love because it is a way to punish people for their own well being. In this sense it can be comparable to prisons but the difference is that a prison is suppose to correct people before resending them out into society. In Dante's hell, you cannot leave hell once you end up there. This is why I disagree with it being like a prison. I think the loving part of hell is the separation of those too evil in order to make it better for the people who got to purgatory or heaven. The primordial love is not intended for those who go to hell because it is an eternal punishment, not one that will someday end and release its prisoner.

    ReplyDelete
  14. The sign into hell was interesting because it said it was raised there because of primordial love. This is love from the beginning. I think it is peculiar that it says this on the sign because the people entering have no hope of leaving. I think it was made out of love because God gave people free will out of love. Because of this God gave people the ability to sin out of love and therefore hell was created out of love and the choice of the sinner.

    ReplyDelete
  15. I like Mac's idea but I disagree with him. I think that Hell is like prison and expresses God's love because it rewards those who have done good. In this way it is similar to prison because that protect the well-meaning citizens from the evil ones. Dante's Hell seperates the worthy from the unworthy just like prison seperates the good from the bad.

    ReplyDelete
  16. The inscription over the gate of Hell, particularly lines 4-6, describe what it is that Hell really signifies. It is "the way to a forsaken people," those people who are doomed to it for eternity, and "sarcred justice" moved God to make it, because those who are in hell have fundamentally rejected God's grace. The lines which feel at first glance so confusing to the reader must also be viewed in this context: as a description of Hell. Hell, like any other creation of God, embodies ALL of his attributes--God cannot be inconsistent. Personally, I agree with Martha's interpretation, which is that "primordial love" doesn't refer to the people who are entering hell, but to those who are not. In other words, God raised Hell with the love of those who go to heaven in mind.

    ReplyDelete
  17. When i think of God i think of love, however i was taken aback when it was used in describing the gate of hell. After our discussion it does make sense though. I agree with Martha's statement that a prison (hell) protects the good and virtuous citizens. I think that God made hell with intellect, omnipotence, and love because those are the three things that He consists of. God is all-knowing, powerful, and full of love. He uses his love in making hell to protect the people who acknowledged Him. It can also be to show the souls in hell that they ultimately chose to be there since God is forgiving and grants us free will.

    ReplyDelete