What is the meaning of the novel's ending? Luis, a seemingly minor character, provides the final, powerful image of the novel. What is the significance of the last paragraph?
The massacre of the whiskey priest alludes to a victory for the lieutenant. He has finally achieved his goal, saving future generations Mexico from the "evil" religion. Yet, Greene uses this moment to address a new chapter, a new hope. The fact that Luis has come to comsider the whiskey priest to be a hero, and has come to hate the lieutenant (shown through Luis spitting at him) is a testimony to the lasting effect the whiskey priest has made. Towards the end of the chapter, Luis goes to sleep has a dream. This dream may be considered as a resurrection for the whiskey priest, again we see that his influence lives on. Greene uses Luis in order to channel his final message, the Church will endure. Clearly illustrated by the knocking of the stranger on Luis's door. Luis gets up and after brief questioning, immediately lets the man in. The lieutenant has killed one man, but Luis and the stranger and probably more believers will come to take the hero's place. At least one man has come to live as the whiskey priest did and defy the state. There has been minimal triumph for the lieutenant, and mainly defeat.
I very much agree with what John said. I think that it is very interesting that Greene chooses to bring his novel to a close with Luis, a seemingly minor character. However, I believe that this ending is a very powerful one that shows hope for the future of Mexico. As John said, the fact that another priest has come to the door shows that one man's ideals cannot kill the Catholic faith and that it will survive despite being outlawed. I also think that Luis opening the door, when earlier in the novel it can be assumed that he would not have, shows the hope and power instilled by religion. I believe that it shows how powerful the faith is, and that it is a source of hope for the people of the state.
I definitely agree with what Elizabeth and John have said. At first after reading the ending I was confused as to why Luis would end the story, but after thinking about it, it makes sense that Luis would be used as a symbol to represent the future and the youth of Mexico. His dream shows that the Catholic faith will still live on, and like John said, his spitting at the lieutenant shows how much of an impact the whiskey priest has made. Greene did not want to just end the story with the death of the whiskey priest because that would've seemed liked Catholicism was dead as well. Instead he ties everything together, and his frame story is what makes the novel so unique.
I was actually not that surprised when Greene ended the story with Luis. Luis's character seemed minor, yet all of his actions and thoughts were essential to some of the main themes of the novel. Towards the end of the novel, as Greene tied most of the characters together, I kept waiting for Luis to be mentioned. So when he finally was in the scene where he spit out the window, I was not that shocked. I think Greene ended the novel brilliantly.
The massacre of the whiskey priest alludes to a victory for the lieutenant. He has finally achieved his goal, saving future generations Mexico from the "evil" religion. Yet, Greene uses this moment to address a new chapter, a new hope. The fact that Luis has come to comsider the whiskey priest to be a hero, and has come to hate the lieutenant (shown through Luis spitting at him) is a testimony to the lasting effect the whiskey priest has made. Towards the end of the chapter, Luis goes to sleep has a dream. This dream may be considered as a resurrection for the whiskey priest, again we see that his influence lives on. Greene uses Luis in order to channel his final message, the Church will endure. Clearly illustrated by the knocking of the stranger on Luis's door. Luis gets up and after brief questioning, immediately lets the man in. The lieutenant has killed one man, but Luis and the stranger and probably more believers will come to take the hero's place. At least one man has come to live as the whiskey priest did and defy the state. There has been minimal triumph for the lieutenant, and mainly defeat.
ReplyDeleteI very much agree with what John said. I think that it is very interesting that Greene chooses to bring his novel to a close with Luis, a seemingly minor character. However, I believe that this ending is a very powerful one that shows hope for the future of Mexico. As John said, the fact that another priest has come to the door shows that one man's ideals cannot kill the Catholic faith and that it will survive despite being outlawed. I also think that Luis opening the door, when earlier in the novel it can be assumed that he would not have, shows the hope and power instilled by religion. I believe that it shows how powerful the faith is, and that it is a source of hope for the people of the state.
ReplyDeleteI definitely agree with what Elizabeth and John have said. At first after reading the ending I was confused as to why Luis would end the story, but after thinking about it, it makes sense that Luis would be used as a symbol to represent the future and the youth of Mexico. His dream shows that the Catholic faith will still live on, and like John said, his spitting at the lieutenant shows how much of an impact the whiskey priest has made. Greene did not want to just end the story with the death of the whiskey priest because that would've seemed liked Catholicism was dead as well. Instead he ties everything together, and his frame story is what makes the novel so unique.
ReplyDeleteI was actually not that surprised when Greene ended the story with Luis. Luis's character seemed minor, yet all of his actions and thoughts were essential to some of the main themes of the novel. Towards the end of the novel, as Greene tied most of the characters together, I kept waiting for Luis to be mentioned. So when he finally was in the scene where he spit out the window, I was not that shocked. I think Greene ended the novel brilliantly.
ReplyDelete