What are your reactions to the depiction of Satan at the end of Inferno? Were your expectations met? Explain. (Perhaps it will be useful to contrast Dante's treatment with Milton's in Paradise Lost).
Why did Dante depict Satan in this way? What does it mean? Was there any of the typical Dante narrative drama in the last canto?
You are allowed to compose more than one paragraph in responding to these prompts. : )
Sea
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI will admit that I was a little let down when Satan was depicted at the end of Circle 9 in Dante’s Inferno. Throughout the whole journey there are references to Satan being at the farthest point from God, and how Dante will eventually have to travel to that horrible spot in Hell. The description of him is quite graphic because of the three heads, monstrous size, and constant meal of Judas, Brutus, and Cassius. However, I think that for such a important moment it was a little too short and it would have been much more interesting if Dante got to converse with him. It was interesting but somewhat anti-climactic.
ReplyDeleteI think that Dante intentionally made the introduction of Satan a somewhat “letdown” to support what he has said throughout Inferno. Back in Canto III when we first saw the gate of hell, we learned that God made Hell with His omnipotence, intellect, and love. We saw many examples along Dante’s journey that God is in charge in Hell. Dante’s depiction of Satan is the final emphasis that Satan has no power in Hell and is trapped there just like the other sinners. There was still good narrative drama in the last canto, especially with the climb out of Hell. The climb is engaging but also helps wrap up the idea that one must directly confront and understand sin to be able to overcome it. “There is no way but by such stairs to rise above such evil.”
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI have to agree with Stacy in that I too was disappointed in the depiction of Satan at the end of Circle 9. Whenever I picture Satan, I see a monstrous, powerful man who rules Hell with an iron fist and creates trouble for everything on Earth. With Dante's powerful descriptions throughout Inferno, I was expecting the cliché fiery hell-pit of Satan written with an eloquence that only Dante can create, but got just the opposite. Dante’s Satan, although still described by Dante’s astute rhetoric, is quite powerless. As Stacy pointed out, this has been foreshadowed in Dante’s numerous references to the fact that God is in charge and that those who “rule” hell have only the illusion of power, but the idea of a Satan encased in ice was just very surprising.
ReplyDeleteI would have liked Dante to have spoken to Satan, as well. Right when Dante finishes the description of Satan devouring Brutus and Cassius, Virgil proclaims that they have seen everything and it is time to go. Virgil and Dante have a habit of departing quickly from many of the circles, but this departure seemed exceptionally rushed. Being at the center of Hell, Satan is the farthest thing from God and I would have thought Dante would come to some sudden epiphany of not having to fear the creatures of Hell because God is always in control, or perhaps of the lesson that Virgil was trying to teach him about not feeling pity for those in Hell, or just something to epitomize the journey that Dante has undergone. I guess I was expecting a big finish, and was let down slightly. Perhaps that is Dante’s way to get readers to continue into the next books.
I think that the depiction of Satan at the end of Circle Nine was indeed a disappointment. All throughout Inferno, it is implied that the last part of Hell is the worst and that Satan is a feared creature. Instead, Satan seemed to be simply punished just like everyone else. There was no vengeance or power attempt on Satan's part. Although Dante graphically described Satan devouring Judas, Brutus, and Cassius, I felt as if the description was rushed. I also wasn't haunted by any part of Satan like I hoped to be. Furthermore, Dante and Virgil never stopped to talk to Satan. Why? Was that even possible? Waiting so long and reading so much I had greater expectations than what was presented to me.
ReplyDeleteI agree with Stacy that Satan doesn't have any true power. Heaven and Hell were made by God. He is the ultimate ruler. Anyone who tests or defies God only answers to him. Satan, therefore, is shown furthest away from God in punishment. This might be the final symbol and lesson of Virgil: show no pity for the sinners. Besides this logic, there doesn't seem to be any big, final moment to captivate the audience. It is possible that Dante did this to transition from Inferno to his other books.
Dante's depiction of Satan did not quite reach my expectations. I felt the entire story had reached a climax where we were going to read about more of a gruesome, terrifying creature than a three headed monster with wings. In general I don't think Circle 9 quite lived up to my expectations because I didn't feel like the punishment was as painful or degrading as some of the other ones like the boiling blood or transformation into reptiles. I expected Satan to be more of a mastermind behind all of the punishment rather than just another monster in the pit.
ReplyDeleteHowever, after reading Stacy's post this makes more sense to me. She had a great point about how God is in charge/control of Hell- not Satan which is what most people tend to believe. So it would make sense that Dante would depict Satan as just another monster in the circles. I did think it was interesting how the three most sinful people according to Dante were all alone in the last pocket of circle 9 and felt this was fitting. I just felt like their punishment should have had more symbolism and that maybe they could have had a conversation with either Judas, Brutus, Cassius, or Satan himself in order to leave the audience with more closure to Hell. Maybe Caroline is right, however. There isn't any grand finale to the story because it technically isn't over and there is still more to his journey. Dante didn't want his readers to stop there, but to continue into Purgatory and eventually to Heaven.
Although I agree with everyone else that Satan failed to meet expectations of the monstrous, all powerful, beast we all picture him as, I believe that the image portrayed at the end of the novel di exactly what Dante wanted it to do. The final scene of Satan being stuck in the pit of hell is so different to us because our whole lives we have imagined him as the prince of darkness, ruler of the underworld, someone who is in charge in Hell as God is in Heaven. As Stacy pointed out, early on we are taught this is not true. The sign on the gate of hell points out that it is God's creation. When you see the final image of Satan, stuck in a place he probably wants out of it, the symbolism is truly driven home. These are the fallen angels. These are the souls who God wants to punish and does so by trapping them. Satan is clearly at the mercy of God and suddenly he looks weak. This is what I think upsets people about Satan but I also think that it is what Dante wanted to do. He wanted to make clear to the reader that Hell is a separate afterlife. It is an eternal punishment. The symbolic retribution is clear, as these individuals used free will on Earth to make wrong decisions they are punished here by having their freedom eliminated. No one wants to be in hell, not even Satan.
ReplyDeleteI was definitely disappointed by Satan in the ninth circle. I know he had three heads and wings but that dies not seem gross enough. I pictured him to be nearly indescribable, hard to look at, an utterly foul beast. Dante really disappointed me. Throughout "Inferno" he came up with outrageously grotesque descriptions of people, so I was expecting the grand finale, Satan, to be his best masterpiece. I completely corroborate Kelly when she says that Satan just seemed like another monster in the pit. I know that he is not in charge of Hell, but I imagined that he would be much grosser and more monster-like than the other sinners. Additionally, Satan does not even speak. This seems to me to be a lack of power, which contradicts my expectation that Satan would be very powerful. I would have enjoyed if Dante talked to Satan because it would be interesting to see Dante's interpretation of what Satan would have had to say.
ReplyDeleteI think that the three heads of Satan is a great touch, since it could be interpreted as the perversion of the Holy Trinity. The comedy is all about perversions, so it is only fitting that it ends with the greatest perversion of all: the perversion of God Himself in all three forms. This coincides with the comedy's emphasis on distortion rather than creation; Satan is not an evil being that was created from nowhere, he is a distortion of an angel.
I think Satan was disappointing because he was not what I imagined. Contemporary images of Satan paint a picture of an evil dictator ruling over Hell and capable of harming people, making you fear him. However, Dante's Satan was pathetically encased in ice, unable to harm anyone or anything, other than the three bodies in his mouth. While I envision a gross and sacrey looking Satan from Dante's depiction, I do not fear this Satan at all, and that is the disappointment.
ReplyDeleteI think Dante did this on prupose to prove a point. God is the creator of Hell, and He is the only one man should fear. Satan is trap inside God's prison; he cannot escape, and therefore he cannot hurt people, so there is no need to fear him. However, God is the true source of power, and disobeying his law by ignoring his love for us, will cause us pain. We should fear offending God instead of being threatened by Satan, and that is why Dante's imagine of satan is not what we might imagine.
I too was somewhat let down with the depiction of Satan. Throughout the course of Dante’s journey, he makes several comments about Satan being the furthest thing from god, and the center of all evil things. Whenever I picture Satan, I think of a monstrous humanlike creature producing fire and holding a pitchfork. However, Dante’s description proves to be quite different from this. Although Dante described him as having three heads and to be chewing on Judas, Brutus, and Cassius, Satan’s body is half immersed in ice, and therefore he cannot move.
ReplyDeleteDespite my original disappointment, I believe that Dante built Satan up to be this monstrous fallen angel purposely so that we would be let down. As we have discussed in class, Satan has no real power in Hell, only the illusion of it. Satan has been illustrated throughout the ages as a fiery beast that continually tempts us, but that is simply an illusion. He has no real power, he cannot even detach himself from the ice. Therefore, although I was initially let down by Dante’s seemingly benign portrayal of Satan, I see now that it is very fitting for Dante’s powerless Satan.
When I first read the description of Satan, I was definitely disappointed. It seemed very anti-climactic because the whole sotry had been building up to the moment when Dante finally meets Satan and I expected something a lot more eventful. I had hoped there would be some type of confrontation between Satan, Dante, and Vergil, but there was nothing. After thinking about the ending, I realized that, like Mac said, Dante conveyed the image he wanted to convey: Hell was created by God, not by Satan. I know I forgot that concept very easily while reading Inferno, and Dante used this image of Satan as a reminder of that idea.
ReplyDeleteIt makes sense that Dante used this seemingly disappointing image of Satan because it fits with all of the messages and symbolism he uses throughout the story. The number three is brought throughout the work and so it only makes sense that Satan has three heads and that the three worst sinners are punished in similar ways, but still with the worst sinner (Judas) being punished differently from the other two (Brutus and Cassius). Dante wanted to make the point that God is in charge of all things, even sin, and he makes this very clear by presenting Satan and the last three sinners this way.
I, too, was disappointed by Dante’s depiction of the final sinner in Hell. I imagined that Dante would find the language to describe Satan in a more grotesque and monstrous way as he has done Canto after Canto for the monsters of Hell. He has found such unimaginable ways to punish the sinners of Hell, and I expected that the worst sinner of them all, in the very bottom of Hell, to be punished in a more elaborate, disgusting manner. Although throughout Inferno, Dante has emphasizes Satan’s lack of power and constantly stated that God is the source of all power, intelligence, and love, I expected that Satan would have more of a presence in Hell. I thought that Dante would at least have a conversation with Satan, and I was disappointed that he didn’t speak with Satan. I think it would have been interesting to see Dante’s, and Virgil’s, for that matter, interpretation of what Satan had to say. I would have hoped that Dante would condemn Satan in a more violent manner than any other sinner, but that did not occur. I think that Dante was trying to portray, by placing Satan frozen in the ice, how completely powerless Satan actually is in Hell, and that all his power is only an illusion.
ReplyDeleteI agree with Tess when she talks about the three heads of Satan being a perversion of the Trinity. I think this is a very intelligent remark because all of Inferno has been about how the sinners’ actions have been perversions of God, making Satan the ultimate perversion. Therefore, it is fitting that he is a disgusting being with three heads that devour three treasonous men. By turning against God, he committed the ultimate treason.
I was disappointed with the moment when we are introduced to this Satan as well. I was thinking thourghout the rounds, all these punishments have been so hateful even in the first couple that this Satan would be the one that would put others to shame because he would display the true hatred and power that hell comes to show. This Satan in plain thoughts would be fear. When Dante even failed to speak with him I was even more disappointed because of all the descriptive naratives that Dante has dexcribed prior. I was expecting a great tale or conversation from Satan, but instead we were left with nothing. Satan was left as basically just another monster in the cantos.
ReplyDeleteHowever when I went back and reanalyzed what exactly Dante meant by this scene, I also thought what Elizabeth did that perhaps this was to show that Satan is not the pictuered image of what Hell is as everyone expects. Dante wants Hell to be seen as not a place where there is an all-powerful ruler in a place of punishment, but rather Satan is just as powerless as any other person or monster in Hell. He too is in punishment, he is not a ruler. As always, Dante had to use some kind of perversion between Hell and God, so in this way he used Satan's three faces to be a perversion to the Holy Trinity. So perhaps Dante's Satan was not as much a disappointment as first expected.
I was dissapointed in the image of Satan at the end of the inferno. I was expecting the typical image of Satan that we usually see which is a terrible tyrant who rules hell. Satan is usually depicted as a bitter pure evil monster who wants everybody else to suffer as he does. However Dante's version does make sense for his novel. Throught the story Dante constantly reminds us that divine love through God is all powerful and the only way to salvation. Next to this nothing is powerful which is why while we may think of Satan as the King of hell, according to Dante he is really the King of nothing. He is as much of a prisoner as everybody else.
ReplyDeleteI honestly had no expectations for Satan at the end so I was not let down. Despite my mostly forgetting that satan was in circle 9, I think Dante's interpretation set a very fitting tone for the end of the novel. As we have progressed through the circles, the sinners wish to be remembered less and less. So this would explain why Dante wouldn't have his normal narrative with any sinners because none of them want to be known or for people to know where they are.
ReplyDeleteIn respect to satan himself, I think his punishment and his position in Hell is very symbolic. I like the idea that he "dug his own hole" and that his wings are keeping him frozen in it. He chose how he felt towards God and he got his wish to be as far away from him as possible. Still, as he "rules" Hell, God retains full power over everything leaving Satan helpless in his own domain.
I was extremely disappointed in Dante's depiction of Satan. I had expected a distorted, cruel, vicious looking creature who looked as if his skin was burning from the inside out. The depiction of three mouths to feed was interesting to interpret. I was looking forward to the prue evilness of Satan being presented in actual form. The buildup of Satan was so profound that his lack of presence in circle nine was disappointing and surprising. I would have been very interested to see interaction between Dante and Satan, maybe even Virgil as well.
ReplyDeleteDante intentionally downplayed the vision and presence of Satan in circle nine to reinforce God's presence in hell. Even in circle nine, God seemed present and the lack of heaven seemed present. It fits into the message and themes of the entire novel. Satan had little to no power which remained consistent throughout the entire novel. According to Dante and God, Satan as little power or authority-a statement that remained constant even in the deepest circle of hell.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI was dissapointed when Dante encountered Satan because one expects a powerful satan in the most horrible of punishments. However the depiction of the last round in the last circle goes along with the rest of the novel and the idea of symbolic retribution. One would expect fire and pain in the last level of hell but one finds ice because it works for Dante's narrative. One sometimes imagines Satan as ruling hell but Dante shows that Satan has no power, only God does, and Satan is a prisoner of his own choice and is actually keeping himself there by beating his wings. I found it peculiar that Satan was weeping considering he is the root of all evil I did not expect him to cry. In the last round of hell Dante is still consistent with his symbols but also with telling a story because he continues to lead the reader on to continue with the next part of the commedy.
ReplyDeleteAs I reached the end, I was expecting Satan to be portrayed in a much different way. The whole comedy seemed to be building up to this grand devil that could not be more evil. I felt that the whole story was building up and building up and just ended with a deflated emotion. I agree with Kelly on her point that Circle 9 doesn’t live up to her expectations. It seemed that in Circles 1 through 8 there were much more painful, degrading, harsh punishments. I really am intrigued by Kelly’s comment, “I expected Satan to be more of a mastermind behind all of the punishment rather than just another monster in the pit.” I think that she puts my feelings perfectly. Satan didn’t seem to be
ReplyDeleteHowever, I think that maybe Satan is portrayed in our society as a more of all-evil, horrible, nasty so maybe we, as a society, place more “blame” and “pressure” on Satan to be this horrible creature that rules hell rather than the way Dante portrayed Lucifer. I like how Stacy talks about God and the idea that God is in charge and in control of Hell not Satan. I personally think that our mindsets in contemporary society think of Satan as being in control, when God is truly in control of everyone/everything. Reading the ending, Dante made me think of Satan and Hell a different way. I think that maybe I gave Satan a little too much power in the way that I viewed him.
-Olivia Weiss
I agree with everyone when I say that I too was disappointed with the depiction of Satan because my expectations were not met at all. Throughout Dante and Virgil’s entire journey, we meet monster after monster. I was expecting Satan to be the worst of all and I completely agree with Tess and Kelly when they describe Satan as “just another monster in the pit.” I thought that this particular scene (since it is the climax) would be incredibly detailed and extensive. I was also anticipating some sort of battle against Lucifer, but the scene just seemed to go by so quickly. However, I think judging from Dante’s point of view, Satan was portrayed perfectly. Some people have the misconception that Satan is the creator of hell and that is why they see him as such a dominant, all powerful figure. However, God is the only creator that exists. He is the dominant figure that contains power over everything, including Satan. Like Olivia said, our society gives Satan too much power and authority when really there is no reason to do so. In “Inferno”, Dante is a representation of all humans because he was frightened of Satan and his power; but, he then realizes that Satan has no control at all when he is unable to harm Dante and Virgil. I think this is exactly the lesson Dante wanted us to take away from this comedy – there is no reason to fear Satan because God is our only creator.
ReplyDeleteThe depiction of Satan was indeed somewhat disappointing as a reader. In some ways, I think it is because people in general have a propensity to view Satan as somehow equal to God. We hear the priest's sermon of a dangerous creature named Satan, who is the opposite of God in every way, and his enemy. But we do not see the spectrum of goodness and evil, which the priest sees. Rather, We tend to favor the spectrum of power. And on that spectrum, it is an easy enough thing to imagine that Satan is in fact the equal of God. That he is somehow an infinite evil, a terribly powerful being. But he is of course not, and Dante portrays this reality faithfully.
ReplyDeleteLike everyone has already stated, Dante's picture of Satan goes against our conventional wisdom of who Satan is. Hell is supposed to be the satan's domionion, he is supposed to carry around a pitchfork, sit atop of the throne of Hell, and spit flames. Yet, he is encased in ice; freezed through attempted eternal flight.One wonders why there is enough evil in the world to fill 9 circles of hell, and concludes that it is the work of the king of evil, whom we would call Satan. However, Dante's message is clear, Satan holds no power and God is the almighty. Like Alana, I believe Dante is trying to tell us that Satan is nothing to fear and we have power over our situation in life. It is eveident that getting out of the dark wood is up to us, not Satan.
ReplyDelete