Tuesday, March 8, 2011

King Lear

Act One:  comments, insights, epiphanies, questions, predictions, sudden moments of sparkling brilliance

13 comments:

  1. Based on what we have read in Act One, I predict that the Fool is definitely being used as a means of foreshadowing in King Lear. He is trying to convince King Lear of the wrong decision that he has made by splitting up his kingdom between Regan and Goneril which makes me believe that eventually King Lear will come to realize that the Fool is right and that he has made an awful mistake in 1) splitting up his kingdom and 2) banishing his favorite daughter.I think that even though Cordelia has been banished, by the end of the play she will return and make amends with her father and Kent will reveal himself to King Lear as well. Like we discussed in class, because the characters that seem to be the most good- Kent and Cordelia- love the King, this must mean that they see good in him which ultimately makes me believe that he will fix his mistakes.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I just find it ironic how un-foolish the Fool truly is. I found the parts with him to be the hardest of the play to read so far because he is constantly using figures of speech. Usually, the common people are supposed to be easier to understand, while the wealthy are supposed to be learned, and therefore well versed and harder to understand. However, it is reversed here. Also reversed are the roles of Lear and the Fool according to wisdom. Kings are supposed to be wise, but here the Fool is more wise than the King.

    I also love the lines about nothing. I feel as though Lear will find out that something can come of nothing, because within Act One he said "Nothing will come of nothing" two times already, which was first rebuked by Cordelia and then the Fool, both of which I would label as wise characters.

    ReplyDelete
  3. From Act 1 I found the remarkable resemblance I thought between the bastard son here and the bastard son in Much Ado about Nothing. They both try to aggravate two sides causing the others to jump to conclusions, rather than listen to what the two sides have to say. I also found that Lear displayed the slightest regret towards banishing Cordelia after he has been told to not bother Goneril. This is possibly the reasons of realizing truly who this daughter is compared to the one who he banished. He realizes that those words that were spoken by Goneril were exactly what Cordelia said they were, ridiculousness. Overall, this play foreshadows the unusual idea that these people are exactly who we think they are.

    ReplyDelete
  4. From what we have read and discussed in Act One, I believe that my opinion of some of the characters has changed. In the beginning, I did not like King Lear. He seemed too cruel and irrational. By Scene V, I began to understand his actions and see a potential good in him. With Goneril and Regan, however, I only found hatred. I still do not understand why they hate their father so much. They are the ones who have received all the inheritance. What more do they want?
    Edmund reminds me of Don John in Much Ado About Nothing. Both are bastard sons who appear to be good. They are trying to regain a place in the family. In reality, though, they are plotting against the family to win something.
    A character that I like from the start was Kent. Even after King Lear banishes him, Kent sticks around. His priorities and loyalty are well administered throughout the whole Act.I predict that Kent will be the one who brings Cordelia back and resolves the strife among the family.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Scene 1 was a hufge eye opener for us into the world of the play. As we got to know the characters we started to see the direction Shakespere wanted the play to go. One of the things that struck me in the beginning was King Lear's reaction to Cordelia saying that she did love him as much as she should love her father, and no more. It was odd that the King took such an offence to this statement because it does make sense and highlights how insinscere her sisters are. For whatever reason, however, Lear flips out and banishes her from his kingdom. This calls into questiojn his state of mind in his advanced age and whether or not he should be king. Another thing i found interesting was how the fool treated Lear, yet he didn't get into any trouble. I think the King values the opiniojn of the fool and it will play a large part in scenes to come. A moment of sparkling brilliance, in my opinion, was when Kent decided to come back and serve the king, even though he had been banished on pain of death. I though that this really showed how loyal the King's followers were and it forshadows the fact that kent will do anything for the king, even if it endangers his life.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Personally, I am shocked that two daughters are able to plot against their own father. We talked shortly about this yesterday in class saying that in those times family relationships were different, but nevertheless I am still unable to comprehend how Goneril and Regan were able to tear their family bonds for wealth and power. Their father is already giving them his kingdom, and willingly handing over his power slowly. The two women have no excuse except impatience and greed to reason for their actions. I am utterly appalled that daughters would treat their father in this way, especially when their father is the King of England. The secretive plotting of Goneril to subvert her father’s authority is absolutely unacceptable and evil. I can only imagine the disrespectful behavior Regan will show towards Lear when he travels there. :p

    ReplyDelete
  7. So far, the character I am most interested in is King Lear. When I first read scene 1, my initial reaction was that (to put it bluntly) he is dumb. The whole exchange with Goneril and Regan expressing their love for him was so strange and bizarre that I just laughed. Cordelia is his best and favorite daughter, and he completely disowned her. He also gave all of his power away and cutting Cordelia off from that power was an even worse move than giving it all away in the first place. Basically, he kept doing all of these things that just made no sense. Lear completely rejects Kent when he tells him he’s screwing up, and that just made me think Lear to be even dumber—clearly Kent really cares about Lear because he tells him the truth, so it doesn’t make much sense that Lear exiled him too. While I think that Lear seems to be dumb, I do have optimism for him throughout the rest of the play because Cordelia and Kent love him. And, as we’ve discussed in class, we are coming to love Cordelia and Kent. If these two characters admire and care about Lear as much as they appear to, then there must be more depth to Lear beyond his initial foolish actions.

    ReplyDelete
  8. In Act One thus far, I am really intrigued by Cordelia. I really like the way she speaks for herself and doesn't let the actions of those around her control her. I am interested by this theme of good vs. evil. The way that Cordelia and Kent seem to represent good and loyalty seems obvious as of right now in "King Lear." I think that that the loyalty and love present in those two characters is a good way to base the relationships that we have with people in our lives. If we place loyalty and love first, then our lives will work at a much better pace and system. I am very excited to learn more about Cordelia and see how King Lear will progress and learn throughout the story. Right now, I am unsure of King Lear and the actions and choices he has made but I believe he will evolve and change with each experience he has.

    Olivia Weiss

    ReplyDelete
  9. After reading Act I, I am most interested in how carefully and thoughtfully Shakespeare develops his characters and how each contributes to the ultimate theme of the play. So far, I find myself developing a liking for King Lear even though his actions annoy me. As we discussed in class, the characters that are easy to love (Cordelia, Kent, the Fool) are loyal to Lear and their sense of wisdom is obvious. Although Lear has done nothing to appeal to the reader, Shakespeare crafts his play so that the reader does have a sense of Lear’s inherient goodness. Edmund’s cunningness reminds me very much of Don John, the bastard son in Much Ado About Nothing, because they appear good and actually are plotting and evil. I am also bewildered by the fact that Lear cannot see past how fake Regan and Goneril are. I think the theme of appearance vs. reality is very interesting in this play, and I am excited to see how the characters further develop.

    ReplyDelete
  10. So far, I am most intrigued by the character Lear. His relationship with his two daughters and the overall family dynamic continue to shock me. The contrast between good hearted and the evil has already proved to be dominant and will give us easy incite to two different sides of a royal family. Kent's loyalty has already presented itself and reassures my hope for a good hearted Lear. Lear's naive outlook on people raises concern and makes me nervous for disasters to come. So far, my favorite part has been Cordelia's reaction to Lear's invitation to suck up to him for power and land. I am excited to watch Cordelia and Lear's relationship develop and mature.

    ReplyDelete
  11. In act I so far I am intrigued by the relationship between Lear and his daughters. He seems to have no knowledge that his daughters are plotting against him and fall victim to their flattery. It is odd that he takes offence to the words that Cordelia says to him. They are logical and sinsere and show how the other sisters are being suck ups. Lear's reaction to Cordelia's comments and the subsequent dissmissal of Kent seems to suggest that Lear has a large ego and can not admit when he is wrong. This seems like a poor makeup for a king, but Kent and Cordelia seem to really care for him which means he can't be a horrible king. I am interested to see who Lear really is and how he adapts to new situations

    ReplyDelete
  12. As far as Act 1, we know that characters such as Edmund, Goneril, and Regan only care about themselves. They will do anything to get to where they want to be in life no matter who they harm along the way. On the other hand, Kent and Cordelia are obviously on the good side and they show that though their love and protection for Lear. I believe that we all have a pretty good sense of who is good and who is bad; however, Lear is the one character I cannot seem to read. Here is man who is asking his three daughters to prove who loves him the most through words, not actions. He is acting extremely irrational and naïve in the sense of whom he is trusting. However, Kent and Cordelia still love him dearly. Since they are the two characters that I have been the most impressed by, I would trust their judgment the most (as opposed to the other characters). There has to be a reason why they care for Lear so much which is leading me to believe that Lear also is a good person. I believe that they will both remain faithful to the King, and I am anxious to see when Lear will realize who truly cares for him.

    ReplyDelete
  13. In Act 1 the family dynamics were disconcerting yet oddly similar to some families today. First there is a sense that King Lear has to "buy" love from his daughters and that just being in the father-daughter relationship is not enough. Secondly, there is strong sibling rivalry between Goneril and Regan when Regan takes the shot at her sister while professing her love to her father. Finally, the fighting over inheritance is still something many families do today.

    Although the fool has only had a relatively small part so far, I feel as if he is the most knowledgable. The fool is almost a third party observer as he sees the happenings outside of the actual action, yet is able to tell the king his opinions, even if only through jokes. He also seems to be the wisest of them all.

    ReplyDelete