Thursday, April 7, 2011

King Lear

Comment on Lear's prayer in the storm ("You houseless poverty," III.iv.26-36).  What is he saying and what does it say about Lear?

17 comments:

  1. In contrast with the scene in the beginning where Lear has people tell him how great he was, comes Lear's speech in Act 3 Scene 4 lines 30-40. It is here that Lear drops to his knees and prays for those who have to deal with the storms every night, which he is alone dealing with tonight. He here is humbled by his actions and realizes that there is more to life than being a tyrant. He recognizes that he now is just like any other "wretch" out in the storm. He is a failure at life. He has never before thought of the people so lowly in his society. It is a change in the winds now. He, who had once been at the top of the food chain having others tell him how much they love him, is now found in the middle of the storm without any shelter. This shift in powers is in fact where this play becomes not so much about the Lear family, but instead having to do with the affairs of human beings in general.

    ReplyDelete
  2. In the beginning of Act III sc. iv, there is a symbolic connection between the storm outside and Lear's own mental disturbance. Lear explains to Kent that he does not mind the storm. Lear's sensitivity to the storm is blocked out by his mental and emotional anguish and by his obsession with his treacherous daughters.
    Lear continues to show a deepening sensitivity to other people. This trait was missing from his personality in the beginning of the play and is now an interesting side affect of his increasing madness and exposure to human cruelty. In line 30, Lear kneels down and begins to pray for the poor. This is the first time that Lear thinks of someone else besides himself. He is genuinely worried about them. In lines 36-37, Lear actually criticizes himself and admits a fault "I have ta'en too little care of this." Lear urges himself to "expose thyself to feel what wretches feel" (line 35). This self-criticism and new-found sympathy mark the continuing humanization of Lear. There is a transformation afoot and the audience is more than willing to relate to Lear.

    ReplyDelete
  3. In these lines, King Lear finally admits that he did some wrong when he was in charge. This is the first notable time in the play that Lear admits he was wrong and does not look for compliments or praise. His tragic experiences have humbled him to the point where he now sides with people he used to never acknowledge. His words about the terrible plight of the poor exemplify his enormous downfall. The only reason he knows enough about the poor now is that he himself is poor. These lines also assist in the play’s transformation from a family drama to the human drama. Lear is discussing the importance of walking in other people’s shoes. Since he now is experiencing the life of a poor man, he realizes that when in power, he was completely wrong about them. He is advising the “pomp”, or the powerful, to “feel what wretches feel” and give them their surplus money. Essentially, Lear is speaking about generosity and caring for human beings who are struggling. Finally being in the position of the needy has made him realize how much help the poor really need.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Macbeth’s relatively short speech takes the reader into his minds and we are able to see how truly crazy he has become. A couple of times Lear uses the term houseless when addressing the fool and others, however ironic this is, it is extremely sad. Lear is in the same boat as the fool, houseless, yet he can not sense that. Just like we have previously in the act, we begin to feel empathy for Lear. It does not help that he is going insane either. He wonders how homeless people are able to combat the elements and survive. Unlike when Lear said the rain did not affect him, it is evident that now he grips the power of nature upon him. However, he wants to take this adversity a step further. He wants to, “expose thyself to feel what wretches feel.” It can not b denied that Lear considers himself to be a wrench. To him, it follows that he proceeds to take his clothes off. He states that he does not need them, if he needed 100 knights earlier, how can he possibly consider clothes as an excess? In other words, we see the transformation and degradation that Lear has dealt with, he truly is like the fabled Tom o’ Bedlam.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I think thus far, the “You houseless poverty” speech said by Lear in Act III is the most important speech in the play. While it is overlooked to other major monologues such as “O reason not the need”, I think this speech shows the transformation of Lear’s character as he goes from having everything to having absolutely nothing. He now understands the difficulties and hardships that one goes through when they are living in complete poverty. The king, of all people, finally knows what it’s like to be abandoned and he sincerely apologizes for not being considerate of those in need in the past when he says “O, I have ta’en Too little care of this” (36-37). While Lear is going mad with grief and shock from what his daughters are doing to him, I think this shows that through the hardship and pain he is learning a very valuable and important life lesson. His point of view on life has changed completely from when he was saying his “O reason not the need” speech. When he says “Expose thyself to feel what wretches feel” (38) I think he says this as a challenge to others. He wants to share this new found information and point of view that he’s discovered; he wants everyone to understand what it feels like to have nothing. Also, as we discussed in class, this speech not only shows the transformation of Lear, but also the transformation and development of the play itself. It can no longer solely be called “A Family Drama” because it is so much more than that. It touches upon existential questions about the divine, justice and the meaning and value of life itself.

    ReplyDelete
  6. In Act 3 scene 4, Lear shows a transition from his selfish and self-centered nature to someone who is more aware of the world around him. He recognizes the hardships people have to endure and almost has difficulty imagining how people could deal with this all the time. He is feeling solidarity with others for the first time in the play and is thinking about someone other than himself. Throughout the first and second acts, it was all about him. He wanted love proclaimed to him, he was insulted by his daughters, he needed 100 knights, and he was king. This is the first time Lear really considered other people. Also, he is somewhat remorseful that he has been living so separated from some of hardships people in his kingdom have to deal with and that he never did anything about it when he ruled. This is a turning point for Lear and it begs for the audience to reevaluate his character.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Lear's storm speech in Act 3, Scene 4 is a complete reversal from his speech at the end of Act Two. His rant exemplifies his unsettled and confused state of mind just before he enters the hovel. He is asking the Gods to bring even stronger and more powerful storms, for the distract him from the pain of evil daughters; he goes so far as to call for the end of it all. It is very clear that Lear is going mad. At the end of Act Two when Regan and Goneril attempt to take away all his knights, he exclaims, "O, reason not the need! Our basest beggars are in the poorest things superfluous." Here he is saying how dare you ask me why I need them; I don't have to explain myself to you. I want my knights, so I shall have them. He goes on to say that even the poorest beggars have some small thing that they do not truly need. Here in the storm scene, we see a contradiction to the previous narcissistic point of view of Lear. Lear now prays for and pities the poor that are out in the storm, now that he has experienced their hardship. He wonders how they make it through such nights with no warm clothing, food, or shelter, and he ultimately regrets not doing more for these people when he was in power.

    ReplyDelete
  8. The passage beginning in line 27 and continuing through line 41 marks a turning point in Lear’s personality and life. Up until this part in the drama, Lear has appeared to be a very selfish and vain king who is only concerned about himself. This epitimizes in his testing of his daughters affections. But here, in this speech, Lear is finally able to sympathize with other people. By saying “O, I have ta’en too little care of this,” in line 37-8, Lear takes responsibility for not taking better care of his people. While he ruled, he never thought of anyone but himself, but now that he knows what it is like to be abandoned and left out in the cold, he feels true and deep sorrow for not being a better king. In this passage, Lear acknowledges the big difference between needs and wants. At the end of Act 2, when he supposedly thought himself to still be sane, Lear makes a comment regarding what he “needs.” But later, in this passage in Act 3, when Lear has supposedly lost his wit, he realizes the grand difference between a need and a want. Only when he has been exposed to the horrible deprivation of extreme poverty can Lear truly see that everything he wants is not actually necessary. His accumulation of material possessions took precedence over him realizing the faulty nature of his two eldest daughters. The two of them were soley after his kingdom and his wealth, while Cordelia only wanted his love. She was the happiest of the three because she was not materially possessed, but rather she loved him for who he was. In this passage he expresses his regret for the way he lived before being thrown out. While he had whatever he wanted, many of his subjects suffered from not having anywhere to sleep at night.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Thus far in the act, his daughters have betrayed him. Not only have they told him to get rid of all his knights but they also shut him outside in the storm. In this particular scene, Lear is talking and it is just before the point where he meets Edgar. The way he speaks reveals his mental condition: crazy, unstable, and confused. Lear seems distraught and helpess. He begins to pray for the poor. Lear, now in the same position that so many people have been in, feels guilty that he did not care for people with needs such as this. He says, "O, I have ta'en/too little care of this." As Lear waits outside, while the fool goes in, he ponders his reign and what he lacked to care for. As he waits, little does he know that inside the fool meets a spirit that turns out to be Edgar.

    ReplyDelete
  10. King Lear’s speech in lines 30-41 in Act III scene iv shows an extremely important side of Lear that helps the audience to analyze his character more justly. At this point in the play, Lear is at a very vulnerable place within himself and he truly realizes that he has done wrong. Goneril and Regan have shut him out, he is stuck in a storm, and all of the sudden he sees himself equal to a beggar. This epiphany that he has experienced (going from seeing himself as the high and mighty king he once was to a low and poor beggar with no place to go) shows that Lear now understands that he has done wrong—both as a king and as a father. As a king, he realizes that he never did anything to help the homeless, and now that he understands the hardships those people go through, he regrets his negligence: “O, I have ta’en/Too little care of this.” He even goes so far as to cry out in prayer for the well-being of impoverished people: “”Take physic, pomp./Expose thyself to feel what wretches feel,/That thou may’st shake the superflux to them/And show the heavens more just.”
    This shift in opinion shows a shift in character and the most significant shift in character that this speech shows has to do with Lear’s narcissism. When the audience first met Lear, he was demanding his daughters (the only people in the play who are obligated to love him by blood) to express their love for him in exchange for his power and kingdom. This is the ultimate narcissistic thing to do, and one can’t help but let this selfish image of Lear stick with him throughout the play. Other characters’ love for Lear (such as Cordelia and Kent) keep the audience waiting in hope for a reason to love Lear too. This moment is undoubtedly present in this speech. In this scene Lear shows true compassion and empathy for impoverished people (thanks to Edgar disguised as “Tom”) and for once considers someone’s feelings other than his own. It is very difficult to continue with negative feelings about the old man after this scene becauseas he goes mad, he makes sense of the situation as well, and he comes to understand what is truly important. This moment opens the door for many other people to fall in love with Lear, right alongside Kent and Cordelia. It suggests that while Lear did make a mistake by giving everything away, perhaps it was better for himself as a person to do so because he would have continued on in his narcissistic ways had he never been forced to experience life as an impoverished, unloved, abandoned old man.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I saw this particular speech in the play as a critical turning point for King Lear. Here is man who in the beginning of the play was treated like royalty – literally. He had people waiting on him at all times, and he lived the life of a true king. He did not seem to worry about the needs of other people in society because he was too absorbed in his own wants and desires. Here, he is showing incredible remorse for the type of person he was. Since his life has crumbled before him he is finally able to understand, and that is the point he is making in his speech. People are unable to fully comprehend the pain and suffering of the poor until they have experienced it for themselves.

    ReplyDelete
  12. The speech in the play reveals the dramatic change that is going on within Lear. At the onset of the play he is very self centered and narcissistic. Lear wants ecerything to be centered around him and much of the inner struggle that he has dealt with is due to the fact that he is no longer relevant. However in this speech Lear shows for the first time in the play consideration for somone besides himself. He speaks of the poor homeless people that don't have homes or any protection from the weather. Lear speaks of them as"poor naked wretches" and says that they "bide the pelting of the pitiless storm." He realizes that he did not do enough for them when he was king and asks the storm to make him feel what they do, telling it to "Expose thy self to feel what wretches feel." Lear thinks this would make the heavens just and help to alleviate some of the guilt that he has felt. This scene represents a complete revaluation of how a Lear percieves the world and how he treats those around him

    ReplyDelete
  13. In these lines Lear is about to enter into a cave to encounter Edgar. At the moment he seems to be at his lowest point, however he internally and spiritually he is the best he has ever been. The storm in is mind is painful when he thinks about his children but at the moment he reaches a calm peaceful state of mind and even though he has lost everything he gains knowledge of how the poor live. He prays for them and for the first time in the book (and maybe his life) he thinks about others. Out there in the rain one sees the contrast of the old self-centered narcissistic Lear and the present calm giving Lear. Unfortunately the knowledge and calmness he gains in this scene he will soon loose to insanity.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Lear’s dramatic speech, which often goes unnoticed when one is reading King Lear, comes at a time of turmoil both in Lear’s life and in his mind. Everything he knows and loves about his life is slowly being pulled away from him by the two people he thought loved him the most. He prayed to the God’s that he would not go mad, and yet in this instance it seems that his mind has gone and he has let his demons take over him. He used to be a self absorbed and narcisstic king, and now he has lost everything.
    He begins this speech by saying that there are things that would hurt him more, but he is already enduring endless amounts of pain. There are people out in the freezing night without clothing and shelter and he pities them. He wonders how they can possibly defend themselves against nature. He asks the powerful to cure themselves and that they must give all the things they do not need to those who do not have anything. He begs them to show the heavens that there is justice in this world.
    This is quite the opposite of the Lear introduced in the first two acts. He used to be a very rich, self-centered, and egocentric man, demanding love from his daughters and bringing one hundred soldiers with him wherever he went. He has been completely brought down by his daughters, and in some ways nature. His daughters have taken over the nature of his personality and brought it against him.
    This speech in a way could reveal why Kent always had so much love for him. Deep down, Lear knows how to be a good person and he clearly knows that the general human race does not fit that criteria. It means that Lear is a good man and he might even be aware that he brought this all down upon himself. Lear is left alone and penniless because of the daughters he bred and raised. He asked to be destroyed, but in a way he already is.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Lear’s speech in Act three shows the beginnings of what may be a major epiphany for Lear. In contrast to the dominant, egotistical, and selfish father who demands his daughter’s pronounce their love for him in act one, the seemingly powerless king now appears compassionate and truly apologetic. The reader now struggles to feel pity for him because just pages earlier we witnessed his narcissism and selfish attitude. Regardless, no one can ignore how depressing and sad this scene is, along with how thought provoking it is. It epitomizes the King’s fall from grace as he kneels praying in a terrible storm expressing his sorrow for those homeless individuals who must sleep in this weather. He regrets never offering these people aid as king. He questions how it is fair and recognizes that he only comes to realize this by being in their position when he says, “Expose thyself to feel what wretches feel, that thou may’st shake the superflux to them and show the heavens more just” (lines 39-41). Not only does his empathy take center stage in those lines but we are once again exposed to the word, “superflux” which Lear uses only lines early. In act 2 he defends the superflux things has, the knights, but by trading shoes he recognizes he was wrong. The contrasting imagery is compelling and empathizes the point Shakespeare is trying to make by showing the total change of thought and character Lear has undergone. Finally, the speech provides an argument into the idea of sharing wealth. It makes the audience wonder what society would be like if all the Donald Trumps of the world pooled their money together and equaled it out. Obviously, as Lear says, it would be a more “just world”. To truly make it happen though, those same Donald Trumps need to “Expose” themselves to a poor lifestyle. Of course by then, it would be too late.

    ReplyDelete
  16. n this speech, Lear is distraught, helpless, and seemingly crazy. He has fallen from grace and his position of power, and the reader can do nothing but feel empathy for this graphic example of the fallen man. He has changed his state of mind completely from earlier in the play, and now realizes how dire his state is. He realizes here that he has fallen, and that he has nothing. In line 38, when he says, “Expose thyself to feel what wretches feel” he challenges others and wants to share his new view of the world; he wants everyone to understand what it feels like to have nothing. He also realizes his own shortcomings as a king, and feels regret for some of his actions in the past. This speech is a dramatic turning point in Lear's life, Lear's thoughts, and the entire play.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Lear’s speech in Act 3 is a turning point in the play. Throughout the play thus far Lear has been irrational, moody, impulsive, and a bit crazy. He is on the path of losing his mind completely and has always been vain and narcissistic. This speech is the first time that Lear doesn’t seem to be acting mad. He is finally looking out for the wellbeing of other people and wants to personally help them. He realizes he is not perfect and he could have helped these poor people when he was in power. He wants justice and equality and encourages the rich to give up everything but their necessities. Lear comes to a realization in this scene and I feel that this is when the true meaning of the play really starts to unfold.

    ReplyDelete