What is your personal reaction to--and aesthetic judgment of-- the tragic arrival of Lear and his daughter at the drama's end? Discuss the ending as it relates to the larger questions explored in Shakespeare's play.
The image of Lear walking on stage with Cordelia’s lifeless body in Act 5 scene 3 of Macbeth is a shocking one. We hear Lear, a king who at one point was all powerful, break down with grief. He is, like the audience, confused. The play centers on the idea of justice, whether it be Gloucester’s justice in having his eyes plucked out for adultery or Goneril’s suicide in retribution for poisoning Regan there is always a method to the gods madness. Often it is brought up by characters and made very obvious to the audience. Up until this point the whole play makes sense. With Cordelia’s death though, all logic is lost. The notion of a balance universe is gone. The most innocent character in the entire play has left and Lear can’t seem to understand it. I think this is why Shakespeare left it in the play. The whole time we are led to believe that the world is fair and balance. That justice is served even if it takes years for it to be, like in Gloucester’s case. In this pre-Christian world, Shakespeare’s character believe if you mess up you get punished. Shakespeare challenges this belief by asking the audience to consider why bad things happen to the good people. He asserts that there isn’t logic in the world. Sometimes things fall outside our control and things happen for no reason. It is bleak, but so is Shakespeare’s entire tragedy. Cordelia did everything right in life. Her actions are virtuous time after time and she is honest, caring and forgiving. Lear struggles to understand why that wasn’t enough. Everything he believes is called into question and the weak, vulnerable, and devastated man who has lost his mind and tries his best to hold onto his daughter for as long as he can-refusing to admit he has lost her- is the result. The play is a tragedy but its more than just a sad story. It’s a reflection on fate and destiny and it makes clear that you never know what you’re going to get. There isn’t order or reason in the world, Shakespeare asserts, and even when everything seems to be going your way it can easily slip away from you.
The scene at the end of King Lear is definitely unexpected. The audience has seen so much tragedy throughout the course of the play and at the very end Shakespeare finds another way to twist the plot. Everyone expected Lear to die because it only seemed fitting for the tragedy of his namesake, however Cordelia’s death was not expected. Cordelia symbolized innocence and love. She cared for he father even when he disowned her. The sight of Lear carrying Cordelia’s body onstage shocks everyone and is indescribable. The theme of justice is seen everywhere in the play, especially justice from the gods. The gods seem to do their job correctly with Regan and Goneril, but Cordelia’s death does not make sense because she did nothing wrong and was a Christ-like figure in the play. Shakespeare obviously made the conscious decision to kill Cordelia off at the end of the play, and everyone wonders why. I do not know for sure but I think he did that solely for the shock factor. Shakespeare was all about having a good story and his dramatic ending was unique.
When Lear arrived on stage with the body of Cordelia, I was disappointed to say the least. I was definitely hoping that the play could have the fairytale, cliché ending, but due to the title “The Tragedy of King Lear” the reader had to know that, that most likely wasn’t going to happen. When Lear walks on stage and starts his “Howl, howl, howl!” speech, that has to be the most heartbreaking and touching moment of the play. It seems almost cruel of Shakespeare to have Cordelia die right when things are just getting back to how they should be. He finally regains his sanity and seems to have all he needs- the company of Cordelia- and all it once it seems to be snatched away from him. The kingdom isn’t even important to him or a major priority anymore, and it is clear that he is learned this throughout the major speeches he has made during the play- “O reason not the need” to “Come, let’s away to prison.” He finally understands that all he really needs are the people that he loves and that love him back by his side and with that he can get through anything. Even though I didn’t like how things turned out- I think the death of Cordelia was necessary to finish off the play. As we discussed in class, Shakespeare portrayed Cordelia as a Christ-like figure and her death in Act V shows her sacrifice for her father and for his kingdom. With Lear and all of his blood relatives gone, it gives England the chance to be born again and start fresh. I also believe that you couldn’t really consider this play a “tragedy” unless Cordelia died. For Lear death was pretty inevitable and predictable due to his fragile mental state and his old age. By having Cordelia die in the arms of her father, I think it ultimately makes the play come full circle and ties everything together.
In the end of Shakespeare’s King Lear, Shakespeare ends the play with a bang: Cordelia’s death. As a reader, I still had hope for the end of the play. I was hoping Cordelia could be the victor who continues to “fight for evil.” I assumed Lear would die, because it is “The Tragedy of King Lear,” but I was hoping that he would be the only protagonist killed off and that Cordelia would be able to continue Lear’s tradition of greatness in England. I would have been so much more satisfied if Cordelia could have taken over. Shakespeare, however, likes his plays to be memorable and can never end a tragedy as expected or with something happy. Cordelia’s death was a huge shock for me as a reader and I almost wanted to cry for the future of England. She seemed to be such a good, kind-hearted person in the few scenes we saw her and could have been an amazing leader. She was a symbol of innocence, a Christ figure, and the ultimate sacrifice. The end of the play left a huge impression on me, which I think is what Shakespeare was trying to do. He is able to evoke emotional responses in many of his works, and in King Lear he does this in many ways, but especially by killing Cordelia.
Reading the play for the first time, the second part of scene iii was completely unexpected. When I read Lear’s “Howl” speech (line 308-315), I immediately felt despair. Lear had gone through so much torture and abuse from his eldest daughters that I kept hoping for a happy ending. Instead, Lear’s words pierce the reader’s heart. They confirm that there is complete evil in the world. From this point on, the reader is speechless. It feels as if the wind has been knocked out of you. Sure Lear had his flaws, but why did he have to end up alone? Thinking over the scene now, I am less caught off guard. Throughout the play, there were clues that Regan and Goneril had something big planned. They embodied evil and stopped at nothing to be on top. This last scene also seems fit as an ending. With all the mishaps, Lear has nothing to live for. Nothing will ever be the same because the people will remember what had occurred. If this is the case, then Shakespeare was whipping the slate clean. He was showing that after such tragedy, something new and good has to happen. By going back to the old, life is being stumped instead of prospering. In the large context of the play, I believe that Shakespeare needed to tie everything together in a meaningful way. Not only did he want to stand out, but he also wanted his audience to intellectually look upon the play and ask life questions. Such situations test justice. Maybe Shakespeare was portraying strife at the time or foreshadowing what could happen when human actions are menacingly executed. Although not my favorite play, I think that the ending was suitable and appropriate.
First off, I was expecting for Lear to be dead, or both Lear and Cordelia would still be living. Not Cordelia alone dead. It is not fair to Lear. He has gone through so much already, it is incomprehensible the suffering Cordelia’s death will now cause Lear. I was expecting for Cordelia to be saved from death in the nick of time, and then be named Queen of England. Lear would be alive to see all of this worked out and know that everything will be okay. However, this is nothing near what Shakespeare creates. While facing inevitable death, Edmund seems to have a change of motive, yet is too late. He tried to save them, but it was not good enough. What it his fault he did not free them earlier? Seemingly, this unwanted death could have been avoided. Still, Shakespeare could have wanted to maintain the image that the world is a cold and desolate place, or could have wanted to oppose the expectations of play-goers. King Lear is a tragedy, yet Shakespeare’s ending makes it almost seems too tragic. Lear does not deserve it; Cordelia did not deserve it either. There is little hope, no promising future, no light at the end of the tunnel; just darkness, depression, and madness.
As I was reading the final scenes of the play, I really wasn’t sure of what to expect. What I wanted was for all of the “good guys” be together and in power at the end. I hoped that Cordelia would take power but still have Lear standing by her side for support, with Kent and Albany there with significant roles as well. While I was thinking about the happy ending I wanted and wondering about what would actually happen, I remembered that this play is a tragedy and when I remembered this, I knew my hopes for a “they lived happily ever after” ending were not going to happen. I was not surprised at all that Goneril and Regan both died, and I thought it was very fitting that the two most evil characters in the play had such tragic deaths. It wouldn’t have worked out for both of them to live in peace and hold so much power, one of them would have had the need to take over everything, and Goneril’s actions seemed to be her way of asserting her own authority within the family as the absolute power. The most upsetting deaths, in my opinion, were Cordelia’s and Lear’s. And while I wasn’t shocked that it happened, I was definitely disappointed. Cordelia really didn’t do anything in the play to deserve what came to her, and it was ironic that the person who served as the symbol of retribution throughout the play is the one who got cheated the most in the end. The speech Lear gives about going away to prison with Cordelia is a great moment filled with emotion. It is heartbreaking to see Lear in yet another state of emotional distress and that gets even harder to see when he brings Cordelia’s body in. These moments brought me back to my initial negative opinions of Lear and it made me feel very sympathetic for him and his mistakes. All in all, this tragic ending was very fitting for such a tragic play. Any other ending wouldn’t have stood up to the standards set by the rest of the play.
The only thing that can compare to the end of King Lear is some of Shakespeare’s other plays, but not even Hamlet’s ending could outdo this one. The biggest shock was all the deaths that fell in line, especially Cordelia’s. Up until that death, everything seemed to be falling in line for a perfect ending, the two women had driven themselves into the ground because of their passions, Edmund had been outed by Edgar, the only thing left was a fairytale ending to occur such as the one by Tate. However, Lear is left with his daughters in his arms. This shows how the play has come full circle. At the beginning, Lear wants Cordelia out of his sight for not telling him how much she loved him, but now he is left begging her to please come back. I think in a way the play completes its cycle of being just. Goneril and Regan were evil people jealous of the other, therefore they each led to each other’s downfall. Edmund was a bastard son and lived up to his name, causing the deaths of Gloucester and many others as well. In a way, the ending becomes just for Lear, because he never appreciated anything he had prior to his downfall, so in repayment his one daughter that actually did truly love him is taken away from him. I think that this may have been Shakespeare’s point to prove that people get what they deserve. He hurt us in this way to make a point to appreciate everything we have in the allotted time we have because we don’t know exactly when life could come to an immediate end or when we could hit our downfall like Lear did.
Personally I thought that the ending of the play was unexpected. I expected Lear to be the one who died and for everyone to be mourning his death. I was not expecting Cordelia to die since she seemed like the purest character in the play and the one who redeemed Lear. The ending was horrifying and there was no silver lining, nothing was left besides despair. In the larger context of the play I think that Shakespear is trying to say that there is no divine justice that everything that happens is up to us. This seems clear because there is definitely no justice in the way the play ended. Maybe if Cordelia had lived one could say that justice prevailed but she did not. The play seems to suggest that justice is non existence and that whatever happens happens. Justice, according to the play seems to be only a man made concept and not divine intervention or else Cordelia would have surely lived.
The scene when Lear carries in Cordelia’s body is an image of pure devastation. It is the climax of all the horrors that have occurred in the play. Cordelia, one of the forces of good in the play, has died right after being reunited with her father. It is a total reversal of what we expect to happen. The readers want Cordelia and Lear to live “happily ever after” and this is a twisted ending hurts the readers. I think Shakespeare wanted this ending to make this a true tragedy. He gave his audience an ending that would stick in their minds, not one that would be just like every other happy ending. This ending is more powerful than another and strongly portrays the true nature of a tragedy.
Chris Martin Lears speech to Cordelia signifies the transformation of his character and soul. He has gone from a selfish King to a man who all he needs to survive is the loving company of his daughter. He has come to terms with his tragic life and is now ready to live it humbly in the cell of a prison instead of on top of a throne. It truly shows how great of a transformation he has accomplished. The tragic ending of King Lear is a proclamation by Shakespeare about the complexity and brutality of life. Life is unfair and sometimes those "more sinned against than sinning" meet unjust ends. But he shows that if we fight for the good in people and defend those who are wronged we will create a place of hope and love that will persist no matter the tragedy. Albany, Edgar and Kent represent these bastions of good who even in vain fight for those they love and that deserve to be loved. Life doesnt have perfect endings but if we fight for the right reasons and causes than hope will survive even if no one else does. It is a sad ending but it is also a real ending. An ending that Should be heeded and revered.
In coming to the end of the play, the tragic arrival of Lear and Cordelia truly shocked me. As a reader, I tend to root for the good guy to win, for just morals to prevail. However, although Regan, Goneril, and Edmund are all punished with death, Lear and Cordelia are seemingly punished as well. Cordelia had a high sense of morals since the beginning of the play, and in Act 5 says to her father: “We are not the first who with best meaning have incurred the worst” (5.3.4-5). She tried to do what was right, but was punished by fate, undeserving of her cruel end. She felt a genuine love and care for her father and used the French army and all of her wills to protect Lear's well-being, while her sisters only had their own well-being and pleasure in mind. It makes me question whether the gods had a problem with the family in general, that they would so swiftly kill the father and his three daughters. Shakespeare was courageous in writing this; it is an upsetting ending to a dramatic story, which many readers may find unpleasant. In fact, Nahum Tate's version of King Lear was used for generations in place of Shakespeare's version, most probably because of the happy ending he provided to the play. Shakespeare supplied a fatalistic sentiment to the play's end. Life does not always end fulfilled and happy; it is a struggle that can sometimes end in tragedy, no matter what kind of person you are. There is a force in the universe, be it a god or something else, that decides our death; we have no true control over our ultimate circumstances.
During Lear's speech in Scene 3 of Act 5, I immediately picked up on the notes of nature in his words, such as birds, butterflies, and the moon. He beckons Cordelia to go away to prison with him, where they will sing like birds in a cage. Lear then talks about a mutual respect between the two characters. He seems very accepting of his fate, that the two will make the most of their time left, listening to stories and laughing, as if their deaths weren't inevitable. They would marvel and speculate about the mysteries of the earth as if they were God's spies. In prison, Lear and Cordelia can outlast any rulers that will come and go while they are incarcerated. Lear seems very accepting and humble at this point, a stark contrast to his behavior at the beginning of the play in Scene 1 of Act 1. He had been very commanding with others, and was overly concerned with possessions and the land that each daughter would receive, hinting that the daughter who flatters him the most is the one that loves him the most and thus would receive the largest chunk of land. Cordelia would not play this ridiculous game and was disowned by her own father for it. He even spoke of the idea that her value and price has somehow fallen, and he would give her away to whoever would accept her. However, at the end of the play, he tells her he would kneel down in forgiveness towards her. Lear’s relationship with Kent also evolves over the course of the play, in that he banishes Kent in Scene 1 for questioning his hasty judgment of Cordelia, and in the final scene shows Kent respect and gratitude. Lear goes through a transformation from a selfish man, more concerned about the fate of his possessions and land than the fate of his daughter, to a man concerned about social justice towards the poor and downtrodden.
The image of Lear walking on stage with Cordelia’s lifeless body in Act 5 scene 3 of Macbeth is a shocking one. We hear Lear, a king who at one point was all powerful, break down with grief. He is, like the audience, confused. The play centers on the idea of justice, whether it be Gloucester’s justice in having his eyes plucked out for adultery or Goneril’s suicide in retribution for poisoning Regan there is always a method to the gods madness. Often it is brought up by characters and made very obvious to the audience. Up until this point the whole play makes sense. With Cordelia’s death though, all logic is lost. The notion of a balance universe is gone. The most innocent character in the entire play has left and Lear can’t seem to understand it. I think this is why Shakespeare left it in the play. The whole time we are led to believe that the world is fair and balance. That justice is served even if it takes years for it to be, like in Gloucester’s case. In this pre-Christian world, Shakespeare’s character believe if you mess up you get punished. Shakespeare challenges this belief by asking the audience to consider why bad things happen to the good people. He asserts that there isn’t logic in the world. Sometimes things fall outside our control and things happen for no reason. It is bleak, but so is Shakespeare’s entire tragedy. Cordelia did everything right in life. Her actions are virtuous time after time and she is honest, caring and forgiving. Lear struggles to understand why that wasn’t enough. Everything he believes is called into question and the weak, vulnerable, and devastated man who has lost his mind and tries his best to hold onto his daughter for as long as he can-refusing to admit he has lost her- is the result. The play is a tragedy but its more than just a sad story. It’s a reflection on fate and destiny and it makes clear that you never know what you’re going to get. There isn’t order or reason in the world, Shakespeare asserts, and even when everything seems to be going your way it can easily slip away from you.
ReplyDeleteThe scene at the end of King Lear is definitely unexpected. The audience has seen so much tragedy throughout the course of the play and at the very end Shakespeare finds another way to twist the plot. Everyone expected Lear to die because it only seemed fitting for the tragedy of his namesake, however Cordelia’s death was not expected. Cordelia symbolized innocence and love. She cared for he father even when he disowned her. The sight of Lear carrying Cordelia’s body onstage shocks everyone and is indescribable. The theme of justice is seen everywhere in the play, especially justice from the gods. The gods seem to do their job correctly with Regan and Goneril, but Cordelia’s death does not make sense because she did nothing wrong and was a Christ-like figure in the play. Shakespeare obviously made the conscious decision to kill Cordelia off at the end of the play, and everyone wonders why. I do not know for sure but I think he did that solely for the shock factor. Shakespeare was all about having a good story and his dramatic ending was unique.
ReplyDeleteWhen Lear arrived on stage with the body of Cordelia, I was disappointed to say the least. I was definitely hoping that the play could have the fairytale, cliché ending, but due to the title “The Tragedy of King Lear” the reader had to know that, that most likely wasn’t going to happen. When Lear walks on stage and starts his “Howl, howl, howl!” speech, that has to be the most heartbreaking and touching moment of the play. It seems almost cruel of Shakespeare to have Cordelia die right when things are just getting back to how they should be. He finally regains his sanity and seems to have all he needs- the company of Cordelia- and all it once it seems to be snatched away from him. The kingdom isn’t even important to him or a major priority anymore, and it is clear that he is learned this throughout the major speeches he has made during the play- “O reason not the need” to “Come, let’s away to prison.” He finally understands that all he really needs are the people that he loves and that love him back by his side and with that he can get through anything.
ReplyDeleteEven though I didn’t like how things turned out- I think the death of Cordelia was necessary to finish off the play. As we discussed in class, Shakespeare portrayed Cordelia as a Christ-like figure and her death in Act V shows her sacrifice for her father and for his kingdom. With Lear and all of his blood relatives gone, it gives England the chance to be born again and start fresh. I also believe that you couldn’t really consider this play a “tragedy” unless Cordelia died. For Lear death was pretty inevitable and predictable due to his fragile mental state and his old age. By having Cordelia die in the arms of her father, I think it ultimately makes the play come full circle and ties everything together.
In the end of Shakespeare’s King Lear, Shakespeare ends the play with a bang: Cordelia’s death. As a reader, I still had hope for the end of the play. I was hoping Cordelia could be the victor who continues to “fight for evil.” I assumed Lear would die, because it is “The Tragedy of King Lear,” but I was hoping that he would be the only protagonist killed off and that Cordelia would be able to continue Lear’s tradition of greatness in England. I would have been so much more satisfied if Cordelia could have taken over. Shakespeare, however, likes his plays to be memorable and can never end a tragedy as expected or with something happy. Cordelia’s death was a huge shock for me as a reader and I almost wanted to cry for the future of England. She seemed to be such a good, kind-hearted person in the few scenes we saw her and could have been an amazing leader. She was a symbol of innocence, a Christ figure, and the ultimate sacrifice. The end of the play left a huge impression on me, which I think is what Shakespeare was trying to do. He is able to evoke emotional responses in many of his works, and in King Lear he does this in many ways, but especially by killing Cordelia.
ReplyDeleteReading the play for the first time, the second part of scene iii was completely unexpected. When I read Lear’s “Howl” speech (line 308-315), I immediately felt despair. Lear had gone through so much torture and abuse from his eldest daughters that I kept hoping for a happy ending. Instead, Lear’s words pierce the reader’s heart. They confirm that there is complete evil in the world. From this point on, the reader is speechless. It feels as if the wind has been knocked out of you. Sure Lear had his flaws, but why did he have to end up alone?
ReplyDeleteThinking over the scene now, I am less caught off guard. Throughout the play, there were clues that Regan and Goneril had something big planned. They embodied evil and stopped at nothing to be on top. This last scene also seems fit as an ending. With all the mishaps, Lear has nothing to live for. Nothing will ever be the same because the people will remember what had occurred. If this is the case, then Shakespeare was whipping the slate clean. He was showing that after such tragedy, something new and good has to happen. By going back to the old, life is being stumped instead of prospering.
In the large context of the play, I believe that Shakespeare needed to tie everything together in a meaningful way. Not only did he want to stand out, but he also wanted his audience to intellectually look upon the play and ask life questions. Such situations test justice. Maybe Shakespeare was portraying strife at the time or foreshadowing what could happen when human actions are menacingly executed. Although not my favorite play, I think that the ending was suitable and appropriate.
First off, I was expecting for Lear to be dead, or both Lear and Cordelia would still be living. Not Cordelia alone dead. It is not fair to Lear. He has gone through so much already, it is incomprehensible the suffering Cordelia’s death will now cause Lear. I was expecting for Cordelia to be saved from death in the nick of time, and then be named Queen of England. Lear would be alive to see all of this worked out and know that everything will be okay. However, this is nothing near what Shakespeare creates.
ReplyDeleteWhile facing inevitable death, Edmund seems to have a change of motive, yet is too late. He tried to save them, but it was not good enough. What it his fault he did not free them earlier? Seemingly, this unwanted death could have been avoided. Still, Shakespeare could have wanted to maintain the image that the world is a cold and desolate place, or could have wanted to oppose the expectations of play-goers. King Lear is a tragedy, yet Shakespeare’s ending makes it almost seems too tragic. Lear does not deserve it; Cordelia did not deserve it either. There is little hope, no promising future, no light at the end of the tunnel; just darkness, depression, and madness.
As I was reading the final scenes of the play, I really wasn’t sure of what to expect. What I wanted was for all of the “good guys” be together and in power at the end. I hoped that Cordelia would take power but still have Lear standing by her side for support, with Kent and Albany there with significant roles as well. While I was thinking about the happy ending I wanted and wondering about what would actually happen, I remembered that this play is a tragedy and when I remembered this, I knew my hopes for a “they lived happily ever after” ending were not going to happen.
ReplyDeleteI was not surprised at all that Goneril and Regan both died, and I thought it was very fitting that the two most evil characters in the play had such tragic deaths. It wouldn’t have worked out for both of them to live in peace and hold so much power, one of them would have had the need to take over everything, and Goneril’s actions seemed to be her way of asserting her own authority within the family as the absolute power.
The most upsetting deaths, in my opinion, were Cordelia’s and Lear’s. And while I wasn’t shocked that it happened, I was definitely disappointed. Cordelia really didn’t do anything in the play to deserve what came to her, and it was ironic that the person who served as the symbol of retribution throughout the play is the one who got cheated the most in the end. The speech Lear gives about going away to prison with Cordelia is a great moment filled with emotion. It is heartbreaking to see Lear in yet another state of emotional distress and that gets even harder to see when he brings Cordelia’s body in. These moments brought me back to my initial negative opinions of Lear and it made me feel very sympathetic for him and his mistakes. All in all, this tragic ending was very fitting for such a tragic play. Any other ending wouldn’t have stood up to the standards set by the rest of the play.
The only thing that can compare to the end of King Lear is some of Shakespeare’s other plays, but not even Hamlet’s ending could outdo this one. The biggest shock was all the deaths that fell in line, especially Cordelia’s. Up until that death, everything seemed to be falling in line for a perfect ending, the two women had driven themselves into the ground because of their passions, Edmund had been outed by Edgar, the only thing left was a fairytale ending to occur such as the one by Tate. However, Lear is left with his daughters in his arms. This shows how the play has come full circle.
ReplyDeleteAt the beginning, Lear wants Cordelia out of his sight for not telling him how much she loved him, but now he is left begging her to please come back. I think in a way the play completes its cycle of being just. Goneril and Regan were evil people jealous of the other, therefore they each led to each other’s downfall. Edmund was a bastard son and lived up to his name, causing the deaths of Gloucester and many others as well. In a way, the ending becomes just for Lear, because he never appreciated anything he had prior to his downfall, so in repayment his one daughter that actually did truly love him is taken away from him.
I think that this may have been Shakespeare’s point to prove that people get what they deserve. He hurt us in this way to make a point to appreciate everything we have in the allotted time we have because we don’t know exactly when life could come to an immediate end or when we could hit our downfall like Lear did.
Personally I thought that the ending of the play was unexpected. I expected Lear to be the one who died and for everyone to be mourning his death. I was not expecting Cordelia to die since she seemed like the purest character in the play and the one who redeemed Lear. The ending was horrifying and there was no silver lining, nothing was left besides despair. In the larger context of the play I think that Shakespear is trying to say that there is no divine justice that everything that happens is up to us. This seems clear because there is definitely no justice in the way the play ended. Maybe if Cordelia had lived one could say that justice prevailed but she did not. The play seems to suggest that justice is non existence and that whatever happens happens. Justice, according to the play seems to be only a man made concept and not divine intervention or else Cordelia would have surely lived.
ReplyDeleteThe scene when Lear carries in Cordelia’s body is an image of pure devastation. It is the climax of all the horrors that have occurred in the play. Cordelia, one of the forces of good in the play, has died right after being reunited with her father. It is a total reversal of what we expect to happen. The readers want Cordelia and Lear to live “happily ever after” and this is a twisted ending hurts the readers. I think Shakespeare wanted this ending to make this a true tragedy. He gave his audience an ending that would stick in their minds, not one that would be just like every other happy ending. This ending is more powerful than another and strongly portrays the true nature of a tragedy.
ReplyDeleteChris Martin
ReplyDeleteLears speech to Cordelia signifies the transformation of his character and soul. He has gone from a selfish King to a man who all he needs to survive is the loving company of his daughter. He has come to terms with his tragic life and is now ready to live it humbly in the cell of a prison instead of on top of a throne. It truly shows how great of a transformation he has accomplished.
The tragic ending of King Lear is a proclamation by Shakespeare about the complexity and brutality of life. Life is unfair and sometimes those "more sinned against than sinning" meet unjust ends. But he shows that if we fight for the good in people and defend those who are wronged we will create a place of hope and love that will persist no matter the tragedy. Albany, Edgar and Kent represent these bastions of good who even in vain fight for those they love and that deserve to be loved. Life doesnt have perfect endings but if we fight for the right reasons and causes than hope will survive even if no one else does. It is a sad ending but it is also a real ending. An ending that Should be heeded and revered.
In coming to the end of the play, the tragic arrival of Lear and Cordelia truly shocked me. As a reader, I tend to root for the good guy to win, for just morals to prevail. However, although Regan, Goneril, and Edmund are all punished with death, Lear and Cordelia are seemingly punished as well. Cordelia had a high sense of morals since the beginning of the play, and in Act 5 says to her father: “We are not the first who with best meaning have incurred the worst” (5.3.4-5). She tried to do what was right, but was punished by fate, undeserving of her cruel end. She felt a genuine love and care for her father and used the French army and all of her wills to protect Lear's well-being, while her sisters only had their own well-being and pleasure in mind. It makes me question whether the gods had a problem with the family in general, that they would so swiftly kill the father and his three daughters. Shakespeare was courageous in writing this; it is an upsetting ending to a dramatic story, which many readers may find unpleasant. In fact, Nahum Tate's version of King Lear was used for generations in place of Shakespeare's version, most probably because of the happy ending he provided to the play. Shakespeare supplied a fatalistic sentiment to the play's end. Life does not always end fulfilled and happy; it is a struggle that can sometimes end in tragedy, no matter what kind of person you are. There is a force in the universe, be it a god or something else, that decides our death; we have no true control over our ultimate circumstances.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
DeleteDuring Lear's speech in Scene 3 of Act 5, I immediately picked up on the notes of nature in his words, such as birds, butterflies, and the moon. He beckons Cordelia to go away to prison with him, where they will sing like birds in a cage. Lear then talks about a mutual respect between the two characters. He seems very accepting of his fate, that the two will make the most of their time left, listening to stories and laughing, as if their deaths weren't inevitable. They would marvel and speculate about the mysteries of the earth as if they were God's spies. In prison, Lear and Cordelia can outlast any rulers that will come and go while they are incarcerated. Lear seems very accepting and humble at this point, a stark contrast to his behavior at the beginning of the play in Scene 1 of Act 1. He had been very commanding with others, and was overly concerned with possessions and the land that each daughter would receive, hinting that the daughter who flatters him the most is the one that loves him the most and thus would receive the largest chunk of land. Cordelia would not play this ridiculous game and was disowned by her own father for it. He even spoke of the idea that her value and price has somehow fallen, and he would give her away to whoever would accept her. However, at the end of the play, he tells her he would kneel down in forgiveness towards her. Lear’s relationship with Kent also evolves over the course of the play, in that he banishes Kent in Scene 1 for questioning his hasty judgment of Cordelia, and in the final scene shows Kent respect and gratitude. Lear goes through a transformation from a selfish man, more concerned about the fate of his possessions and land than the fate of his daughter, to a man concerned about social justice towards the poor and downtrodden.
ReplyDelete